Skip to content

Papers

Logistics & Transportation Networks

Retail Supply Chain Cost Control: A Case Study of JD.com’s Procurement, Warehousing, and Logistics

This paper by Wan Wang from the University of Shanghai for Science and Technology examines JD.com's cost control strategies in procurement, warehousing, and logistics. The study highlights the increasing costs and the need for more data-driven and automated approaches to maintain competitiveness.

Original source: doi.org

Retail Supply Chain Cost Control: A Case Study of JD.com’s Procurement, Warehousing, and Logistics

Ask SCI.AI about this story

📋 本文要点

This paper by Wan Wang from the University of Shanghai for Science and Technology examines JD.com's cost control strategies in procurement, warehousing, and logistics. The study highlights the increasing costs and the need for more data-driven and automated approaches to maintain competitiveness.

Paper: Research on Cost Control of Retail Enterprises from the Perspective of Supply Chain

Authors: 婉 王

Published: 2025

Venue: Operations Research and Fuzziology

Source: https://doi.org/10.12677/orf.2025.151028

Research Background

The rapid growth of e-commerce has transformed the retail landscape, making cost control a critical factor for success. This paper by Wan Wang from the Business School at the University of Shanghai for Science and Technology focuses on the cost control strategies of JD.com, one of China’s largest e-commerce platforms. The study aims to analyze the current state of JD.com’s cost management from a supply chain perspective, evaluate its effectiveness, and identify existing problems.

In the context of the supply chain and AI decision-making, effective cost control is essential for maintaining competitiveness and profitability. The rise of e-commerce has led to increased market competition, and traditional methods such as manual inventory management and basic supplier negotiations are increasingly insufficient. The shortcomings of prior approaches include:

  • Lack of integration between different stages of the supply chain, leading to inefficiencies and higher costs. For example, without integrated systems, companies often face issues like overstocking or stockouts, which can significantly impact operational efficiency and customer satisfaction.
  • Inadequate use of data and analytics to make informed decisions, resulting in suboptimal inventory levels and higher operational costs. Traditional methods often rely on static data and do not account for real-time changes in demand, leading to inefficiencies and increased costs.
  • Insufficient focus on customer retention and the associated costs, which can significantly impact overall profitability. Companies often overlook the importance of analyzing and managing customer retention costs, leading to higher marketing and service expenses.

For instance, traditional methods often rely on static data and do not account for real-time changes in demand, leading to overstocking or stockouts. Additionally, the lack of integration between different stages of the supply chain, such as procurement, warehousing, and logistics, can result in bottlenecks and inefficiencies. The need for more dynamic and responsive supply chains is evident, and companies like JD.com must adopt advanced technologies and data-driven approaches to stay competitive.

The industry context is particularly relevant given the rapid growth of e-commerce in China. JD.com, as one of the leading players, faces intense competition from other e-commerce giants like Alibaba and Pinduoduo. The ability to effectively manage costs while maintaining high service quality is crucial for sustaining market share and profitability. The study by Wan Wang provides a detailed analysis of JD.com’s cost control strategies, highlighting the need for more integrated and data-driven approaches.

Key Findings

Procurement Cost Analysis

The study reveals that JD.com’s procurement costs have been increasing year by year, with significant variations in the number of purchasing personnel. The method used to analyze procurement costs involves examining the relationship between revenue and procurement expenses.

Table 1 shows the procurement costs from 2015 to 2019, indicating a steady increase from 1589.60 billion yuan in 2015 to 4925.00 billion yuan in 2019. Similarly, the number of purchasing personnel, as shown in Table 2, increased from 3293 in 2015 to 8521 in 2019.

The key design and algorithm logic involve using big data to predict market demand and optimize procurement. By integrating historical purchase data, browsing records, and seasonal trends, JD.com can make more accurate procurement decisions. The experimental setup includes analyzing the impact of bulk purchasing and supplier negotiation on procurement costs.

The evidence from the study indicates that while JD.com has managed to reduce the proportion of procurement costs in revenue, the absolute costs remain high. This is partly due to the company’s large scale and the need to maintain a wide range of products. For instance, the study found that the proportion of procurement costs in operating income decreased from 60% in 2015 to 55% in 2019, but the absolute costs continued to rise. The comparison with related work, such as studies by Zhu Danping (2021) and Zhang Xinyi (2024), shows that JD.com’s approach is more data-driven but still faces challenges in terms of supplier management and cost optimization.

One of the key findings is the impact of bulk purchasing and supplier negotiation on procurement costs. JD.com leverages its large-scale operations to negotiate better prices with suppliers, especially for high-demand and high-volume products. However, the study also highlights the challenges in maintaining these relationships, as suppliers may resist further price reductions. The use of big data and analytics helps JD.com to make more informed decisions, but the complexity of the supply chain and the need for real-time adjustments pose ongoing challenges.

Warehousing Cost Analysis

JD.com has made significant investments in its warehousing infrastructure, leading to an increase in warehousing area and a reduction in the number of warehouse staff. The method used to analyze warehousing costs involves evaluating the impact of warehouse size, layout, and automation on overall costs.

Table 3 shows the warehousing area from 2015 to 2019, with a notable increase from 220 million square meters in 2015 to 1190 million square meters in 2019. The growth rate in warehousing area was particularly high, with a 65% increase in 2016 and a 79% increase in 2018.

The key design and algorithm logic involve using smart warehousing systems and automation to reduce labor costs and improve efficiency. The experimental setup includes analyzing the impact of warehouse location, inventory management, and automation on warehousing costs.

The evidence from the study indicates that while the total warehousing area has increased, the number of warehouse staff has decreased, thanks to the adoption of automated systems. For example, the number of warehouse personnel, as shown in Table 4, decreased from 33,153 in 2018 to 29,139 in 2019. The comparison with related work, such as studies by He Suhua (2011) and Chen Meijuan (2021), shows that JD.com’s approach is more advanced in terms of technology but still faces challenges in terms of cost-effectiveness and scalability.

The study also highlights the role of smart warehousing systems in reducing labor costs and improving efficiency. JD.com has implemented various technologies, including robotic systems and automated storage and retrieval systems (AS/RS), to handle inventory and order fulfillment. These systems help to reduce the need for manual labor, thereby lowering labor costs and improving operational efficiency. However, the initial investment in these technologies can be substantial, and the return on investment (ROI) may take time to materialize.

Additionally, the study examines the impact of warehouse location and layout on overall costs. JD.com strategically places warehouses in areas with high demand, reducing transportation costs and delivery times. The use of data analytics to predict demand and optimize inventory levels further enhances the efficiency of the warehousing system. However, the study also notes that the complexity of managing a large and geographically dispersed network of warehouses can lead to additional challenges, such as coordinating inventory across multiple locations and ensuring consistent service quality.

Logistics Cost Analysis

JD.com’s logistics costs are a significant part of its overall expenses, with a focus on self-built logistics networks and third-party delivery services. The method used to analyze logistics costs involves evaluating the impact of delivery methods, network coverage, and third-party logistics on overall costs.

Table 5 shows the logistics fees paid to third-party courier companies, increasing from 12.9 billion yuan in 2015 to 58.23 billion yuan in 2019. The number of delivery personnel, as shown in Table 6, also increased from 35,282 in 2015 to 95,138 in 2019.

The key design and algorithm logic involve using smart logistics networks and real-time data analysis to optimize delivery routes and reduce transportation costs. The experimental setup includes analyzing the impact of delivery methods, network coverage, and third-party logistics on logistics costs.

The evidence from the study indicates that while JD.com has managed to reduce some logistics costs through automation and optimization, the overall logistics expenses remain high. For instance, the study found that the logistics costs as a percentage of revenue decreased from 15% in 2015 to 13% in 2019, but the absolute costs continued to rise. The comparison with related work, such as studies by Zeng Ke et al. (2019) and Guo Junchen (2017), shows that JD.com’s approach is more comprehensive but still faces challenges in terms of cost control and service quality.

One of the key findings is the impact of delivery methods and network coverage on logistics costs. JD.com offers a variety of delivery options, including “next-day delivery,” “same-day delivery,” and “express delivery.” These options enhance customer satisfaction but also increase the complexity and cost of the logistics network. The use of real-time data analysis and smart logistics networks helps to optimize delivery routes and reduce transportation costs, but the need to maintain a high level of service quality poses ongoing challenges.

The study also highlights the role of third-party logistics in JD.com’s logistics strategy. While the company has built a large self-operated logistics network, it still relies on third-party couriers to cover areas where its own network is not available. The logistics fees paid to third-party couriers, as shown in Table 5, have increased significantly over the years, reflecting the growing importance of these partnerships. However, the study notes that the use of third-party logistics can lead to higher costs and reduced control over service quality, as JD.com cannot directly manage these partners.

Limitations

Data Quality and Completeness

One of the main limitations of the study is the potential for data quality issues. The effectiveness of big data and analytics depends on the accuracy and completeness of the data. JD.com’s vast data collection efforts may include noise, missing, or inconsistent data, which can affect the accuracy of the analysis.

The impact of this limitation is that it can lead to incorrect predictions and decisions, potentially resulting in higher costs and reduced efficiency. For example, if the data on customer behavior is inaccurate, it can lead to overstocking or stockouts, resulting in higher inventory costs. Possible mitigations include implementing more robust data validation and cleaning processes, as well as investing in better data management systems. JD.com could also consider partnering with data analytics firms to ensure the quality and integrity of their data.

Data quality and completeness are critical for the success of any data-driven approach. Inaccurate or incomplete data can lead to flawed insights and suboptimal decisions. For instance, if the data on customer behavior is inaccurate, it can lead to overstocking or stockouts, resulting in higher inventory costs. Similarly, if the data on supplier performance is incomplete, it can lead to poor procurement decisions and strained supplier relationships. To mitigate these issues, JD.com could implement more robust data validation and cleaning processes, as well as invest in better data management systems. Partnering with data analytics firms can also help to ensure the quality and integrity of the data.

Supplier Management and Negotiation Costs

Another limitation is the ongoing challenge of managing supplier relationships and negotiating favorable terms. As JD.com continues to grow, the pressure on suppliers to maintain their profit margins increases, leading to higher negotiation and management costs.

The impact of this limitation is that it can result in higher procurement costs and strained supplier relationships. For instance, the study found that the proportion of procurement costs in operating income remained high, despite efforts to negotiate better terms. Possible mitigations include developing long-term strategic partnerships with key suppliers, improving communication and collaboration, and leveraging data to make more informed procurement decisions. JD.com could also consider implementing a supplier performance evaluation system to identify and prioritize high-performing partners.

Managing supplier relationships and negotiating favorable terms is a complex and ongoing challenge. As JD.com continues to grow, the pressure on suppliers to maintain their profit margins increases, leading to higher negotiation and management costs. The study found that the proportion of procurement costs in operating income remained high, despite efforts to negotiate better terms. To mitigate these issues, JD.com could develop long-term strategic partnerships with key suppliers, improving communication and collaboration. Leveraging data to make more informed procurement decisions can also help. For example, JD.com could use data analytics to identify high-performing suppliers and prioritize them for long-term partnerships. Implementing a supplier performance evaluation system can also help to ensure that suppliers meet the company’s standards and expectations.

Customer Retention and Development Costs

The study also highlights the lack of detailed analysis of customer retention and development costs. While JD.com has a high level of customer satisfaction, the exact costs associated with retaining and acquiring new customers are not well understood.

The impact of this limitation is that it can lead to suboptimal marketing and customer service strategies, potentially resulting in higher costs and lower profitability. For example, if JD.com does not accurately understand the costs associated with customer retention, it may invest too much or too little in customer service, leading to either high costs or low customer satisfaction. Possible mitigations include conducting more detailed analyses of customer behavior and preferences, as well as implementing more targeted and cost-effective marketing campaigns. JD.com could also consider using customer segmentation to tailor their marketing and service strategies to different customer groups.

Understanding the costs associated with customer retention and development is crucial for optimizing marketing and customer service strategies. The study highlights the lack of detailed analysis in this area, which can lead to suboptimal strategies and higher costs. For example, if JD.com does not accurately understand the costs associated with customer retention, it may invest too much or too little in customer service, leading to either high costs or low customer satisfaction. To mitigate these issues, JD.com could conduct more detailed analyses of customer behavior and preferences. Implementing more targeted and cost-effective marketing campaigns can also help. For instance, JD.com could use customer segmentation to tailor their marketing and service strategies to different customer groups, ensuring that resources are allocated more efficiently.

Practical Implications

Enhancing Supplier Collaboration

To address the challenges in supplier management, JD.com can enhance collaboration with suppliers by building shared data platforms and entering into long-term strategic partnerships. This will help to improve order transparency, reduce inventory levels, and negotiate better prices and terms.

Specific steps include:

  • Conducting regular evaluations of suppliers to identify and prioritize high-performing partners. For example, JD.com could implement a supplier scorecard that evaluates suppliers based on factors such as price, quality, and delivery performance. This scorecard can help to identify top-performing suppliers and prioritize them for long-term partnerships.
  • Developing a collaborative platform to share real-time data on orders, inventory, and logistics. This platform could include features such as real-time tracking of orders, automated alerts for low inventory levels, and predictive analytics for demand forecasting. By sharing data in real-time, both JD.com and its suppliers can make more informed decisions, reducing the risk of overstocking or stockouts.
  • Working with suppliers to implement more accurate demand forecasting and production scheduling. For instance, JD.com could use machine learning algorithms to predict future demand based on historical sales data, seasonality, and other relevant factors. By collaborating with suppliers on demand forecasting, JD.com can ensure that production schedules are aligned with actual demand, reducing the risk of excess inventory and associated costs.

Investing in Green Supply Chain Initiatives

JD.com can also benefit from investing in green supply chain initiatives, such as reducing excessive packaging and carbon emissions. This will not only help to lower environmental costs but also enhance the company’s reputation and appeal to environmentally conscious consumers.

Specific steps include:

  • Identifying and prioritizing product categories for green supply chain transformation. For example, JD.com could start with high-volume, high-impact categories such as electronics and home appliances. By focusing on these categories, JD.com can achieve the greatest environmental and economic benefits.
  • Collaborating with eco-certified producers to adopt more sustainable production and packaging practices. This could include using biodegradable materials, reducing the amount of packaging, and optimizing the design of packaging to minimize waste. By working with eco-certified producers, JD.com can ensure that its products are produced and packaged in an environmentally friendly manner.
  • Offering “green delivery” options and incentivizing customers to choose environmentally friendly delivery methods. For instance, JD.com could offer discounts or loyalty points to customers who choose green delivery options, such as consolidated shipments or electric vehicle deliveries. By offering these incentives, JD.com can encourage more customers to choose environmentally friendly delivery options, reducing the overall carbon footprint of its logistics network.

Optimizing Warehousing and Logistics Operations

To further reduce warehousing and logistics costs, JD.com can continue to invest in smart warehousing systems and optimize its logistics network. This will help to improve efficiency, reduce labor costs, and enhance the overall customer experience.

Specific steps include:

  • Expanding the use of automated warehouses and robotic systems to handle inventory and order fulfillment. For example, JD.com could invest in more advanced robotics and automation technologies, such as autonomous mobile robots (AMRs) and automated storage and retrieval systems (AS/RS). These technologies can help to reduce the need for manual labor, lowering labor costs and improving operational efficiency.
  • Using data analytics to optimize warehouse locations and distribution routes, reducing transportation costs and delivery times. This could involve using geospatial analysis to determine the optimal locations for warehouses and distribution centers, as well as using real-time traffic data to optimize delivery routes. By optimizing these aspects, JD.com can reduce transportation costs and improve delivery times, enhancing the overall customer experience.
  • Implementing real-time inventory management systems to prevent overstocking and minimize waste. For instance, JD.com could use IoT sensors and RFID tags to track inventory levels in real-time, enabling them to respond quickly to changes in demand and avoid overstocking or stockouts. Real-time inventory management can help to reduce the risk of excess inventory and associated costs, improving overall efficiency and profitability.

Source: https://doi.org/10.12677/orf.2025.151028

Ask SCI.AI Finished reading? Continue with SCI.AI. Explore the related policy, route, company and historical context. Continue asking
Stay ahead of supply chain shifts

One email a week: the stories that matter and new risk events — in English, free.

Prefer RSS? Articles Risk events

Enhancing Supply Chain Visibility with Knowledge Graphs and LLMs
Papers Production & Manufacturing Operations

Enhancing Supply Chain Visibility with Knowledge Graphs and LLMs

Sara AlMahri, Liming Xu, and Alexandra Brintrup present a novel framework that leverages Knowledge Graphs (KGs) and Large Language Models (LLMs) to enhance supply chain visibility. The framework, validated through a case study on electric vehicle supply chains, achieves significant improvements in mapping and tracking critical minerals, extending visibility beyond tier-2 suppliers.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Scan to share via WeChat

Open WeChat and scan the QR code to share

QR Code

Add New Playlist